Multifamily Investment  ·  Est. 2019

Well-located housing, patiently improved.

Sheffer Capital acquires and improves Class A and B multifamily communities in suburban markets across the Midwest, operated for the long term.

720+
Units Acquired
$72M
Acquisition Volume
32
Properties
$47M
Realized Sales
What We Do

Sub-institutional multifamily, managed with institutional discipline.

We focus on Class A and B communities that sit below the radar of large institutional buyers: 20 to 250 units, in stable suburban submarkets with strong household incomes.

Our strategy is straightforward. Buy well, improve the asset and its operations, and hold for durable cash flow and long-term appreciation.

i.

Acquire

Disciplined sourcing in markets we know, with conservative underwriting and capital structures built to hold.

ii.

Improve

Targeted unit renovations, operational upgrades and hands-on asset management that lift both resident experience and NOI.

iii.

Hold

A long-term ownership horizon, with transparent reporting and alignment with our investors throughout.

Acquisition Criteria
Markets
Midwest
Size
20+ units
Vintage
Built 2000 or later
Median Income
$80K+ by zip code
Median Home Value
$300K+ by zip code
Location
Within one hour of a major metro

We are actively acquiring. Brokers and owners with opportunities that fit are encouraged to reach out directly.

Submit an Opportunity
Track Record

32 properties across Metro Detroit and beyond.

Current Portfolio · 7 properties · 231 units
Property
Location
Units
Acquired
Status
Baldwin Square Townhomes
Lake Orion, MI89 units2026
Owned
Milford Collection
Milford, MI46 units2026
Owned
South Lyon Collection
South Lyon, MI26 units2026
Owned
Plymouth Collection
Plymouth, MI18 units2025
Owned
Milford Village Flats
Milford, MI16 units2024
Owned
Donovan Townhomes
South Lyon, MI20 units2022
Owned
Plymouth Gardens
Plymouth, MI16 units2022
Owned
Realized · 25 exits · 493 units · $47.0M in sales
Property
Location
Units
Acquired
Status
Village Court
Ortonville, MI16 units2024
Sold 2025
11 Mile Flats
Royal Oak, MI8 units2024
Sold 2025
Maple Place
Holly, MI12 units2024
Sold 2025
Sugar Pine
Holt, MI27 units2024
Sold 2025
Creekside
Fenton, MI24 units2020
Sold 2024
Harvard Lofts
Royal Oak, MI8 units2022
Sold 2023
Hollyvillage
Holly, MI16 units2021
Sold 2023
Pinehurst
Linden, MI33 units2021
Sold 2023

Leadership

Tory Sheffer

Founder & Managing Principal

Tory is Founder and Managing Principal of Sheffer Capital, where he leads acquisitions, financing, asset management, and strategic direction. He has been active in real estate since 2015 and has focused on multifamily investing since 2019. Since then, Tory has been involved in the acquisition and ownership of more than 720 multifamily units representing approximately $72 million of acquisition volume, primarily across Southeast Michigan. Prior to real estate, Tory founded Superior Recreation Services, a commercial playground construction company, at age 19 while attending college, which he subsequently grew and operated.

LinkedIn

Emmie Sheffer

Asset Manager

Emmie serves as Asset Manager for Sheffer Capital, where she oversees day-to-day asset management across the portfolio, including unit renovations and turns, property performance, investor reporting, and acquisition support. Prior to joining Sheffer Capital full-time, Emmie built and operated an independent insurance agency, which she successfully sold to a larger firm. She graduated from the University of Tennessee with a degree in Communications, where she attended on a full golf scholarship.

Contact

Let's talk.

tory@sheffercapital.com

Investors

Accredited investors interested in current and future offerings.

Register on the Portal

Brokers & Owners

Multifamily opportunities that meet our acquisition criteria.

Send a Deal

Partners

Joint venture, co-GP and capital partnership inquiries.

Start a Conversation